The Flight from Athens to Vilnius: A Political Undershoot
A flaw in the Hamas bomb threat story is why it was decided to warn the Belarusian authorities rather than Ukraine, over which the plane also flew, or Lithuania – since the goal was to “punish the European Union” [...]
The arrest by Belarusian authorities of Nexta Telegram channel founder Roman Protasevich on board an Irish plane travelling from Greece to Lithuania shows that Alexander Lukashenko is far from the provincial dictator that his opponents both inside the country and abroad make him out to be.
There is no point in retelling the story of the Ryanair flight’s emergency landing at Minsk airport, because there are few media outlets that haven’t covered it in detail and from every angle. As a result of this mid-air manoeuvre, Roman Protasevich is sitting in a detention centre, reading out statements through a Telegram channel; Alexander Lukashenko is getting ready to go to Sochi to consult with his Russian counterpart; and countries in the West are calling for an air blockade of Minsk and also the sealing of the Yamal–Europe pipeline.
It is clear, however, that Alexander Lukashenko is not afraid of Western sanctions. At the same time, the ingenuity of the Belarusian special services – if we assume that the message about a bomb on board came from them – suggests that their employees have been taught well.
What is less clear is why, after such a brilliantly executed special operation in Minsk, they are now falling over themselves to say that it was nothing to do with them. Supposedly, the presence of Protasevich on board the Ryanair flight came as a surprise to the Belarusian authorities, while the landing in Minsk, after the flight had already practically reached Vilnius, had been requested by the pilot himself. Finally, why blame the Palestinian movement Hamas for threatening to blow up the plane, as Artem Sikorsky from the Belarusian Ministry of Transport and Communications did, when, the evening after the incident, Hamas spokesperson Fawzi Barhum issued a statement saying that the organisation had nothing to do with the bomb threat on the plane?
“We do not use methods that some other suspicious parties may use. They seek to demonise Hamas and thwart general sympathy for the Palestinian people and their legitimate resistance,” said Barhum.
No bomb, but Minsk instead of Vilnius
A flaw in the Hamas bomb threat story is why it was decided to warn the Belarusian authorities rather than Ukraine, over which the plane also flew, or Lithuania – since the goal was to “punish the European Union”.
In such a situation, no one can force the pilot to land at an airport specified by people on the ground. Only the pilot makes such a decision, since he alone is responsible for the safety of the flight. If the pilot of the flight from Athens to Vilnius had thought it would be safer to land the plane in Vilnius, which was closer, rather than fly to Minsk airport, which was further away, then he would have done so.
The trick was that the warning had stated the bomb would explode in Vilnius. How possible it is to specify an exact location is difficult to say, but the crew had no desire to check the viability of the threat.
By specifying the location, whoever sent the threat removed the pilot’s ability to choose. All he could do was land at the second nearest airport, which was Minsk.
The time that the bomb threat was sent and received remains a slightly hazy part of the story. It is also another flaw in the official version of the Belarusian authorities.
The plane departed from Athens and, before entering Belarusian airspace, it passed through the airspace of Greece, Bulgaria, Romania and Ukraine. Why did none of the aviation authorities in these countries respond to the threat? There are only two possible answers. 1) Whoever sent the threat deliberately waited until the plane was over Belarus, but this makes no sense: from their point of view, the earlier they sent the message, the more time the recipients would have had to respond. 2) The authorities of the other countries displayed appalling negligence by ignoring the threat in total disregard of flight safety regulations.
Sovereignty versus immunity
Like it or not, there is nothing in the actions of Minsk that, on a purely legal level, could be called “air piracy” or could justify any of the other accusations being levelled at the Belarusian authorities by various media outlets.
A sovereign state is sovereign not just horizontally, but also vertically – that is, within its own airspace to the edge of the atmosphere. Accordingly, it has the right to take control of whatever is happening above its territory, even in international air corridors.
The difficulty is that there is no clearly defined “quantitative” standard to determine which situation requires urgent intervention and which is not extreme enough. By default, a threat to the lives of the passengers and crew of an aeroplane or ship is considered a necessary and sufficient condition.
There is, in fact, a very fine line here. A plane is a quasi-territory of the state under whose flag it flies. A plane is considered to be in international airspace as soon as the doors close, even if it is still physically on the ground. But, unlike the territory of an embassy, its passengers do not have extraterritorial rights, which, for example, protected Julian Assange from being arrested by the British police when he was in the Ecuadorian embassy.
Picture of Roman Protasevich inside the State Department on April 23, 2018
It is for this reason that being on board an aeroplane or ship does not give passengers immunity similar to diplomatic immunity, no matter what kind of passport they have with them. If a passenger does not have diplomatic status, he or she must comply with the requirements of the local authorities: leaving the plane, for example, or doing something else.
Therefore, the only limitation on the actions of authorities when it comes to the citizens of other states travelling by plane is the risk of getting a tit-for-tat response in relation to their own citizens abroad.
But, in the case of Ryanair, the Belarusian authorities do not even need to worry about that, because Roman Protasevich is a citizen of Belarus.
It is important to know which laws are in effect and where
Formally speaking, the Belarusian authorities acted in full compliance with the requirements of international flight safety standards.
Until the turn of the millennium, planes were hijacked every now and again because there was absolutely no pre-flight screening of passengers during boarding. Since the terrorist attacks in the US on 11 September 2001, however, safety requirements have become somewhat paranoid. The authorities are obliged to respond to each and every threat, no matter how improbable they may seem. And how they can respond is spelled out in detail. The Belarusian authorities followed exactly this procedure.
After the passengers disembarked from the Ryanair plane at Minsk airport in accordance with these rules, they became subjects of domestic law, and the Belarusian authorities were then able to do whatever they believed necessary with their own citizen. The fact that he was an opposition journalist may have added an emotional and political dimension to the incident, but not a legal one.
There have been numerous instances of a country’s special services kidnapping or killing its own citizens on the territory of another state where they were trying to hide. From the point of view of international law, such actions are illegal because each country has its own laws that are mandatory, including for foreigners. Transferring domestic conflicts to the territory of another state does not make those involved extraterritorial. But, in the case of flight FR4978, there was no incursion into a foreign territory.
Forcing a person to leave the territory of another state or abducting him by force is a crime. But, in this instance, no one forced their way onto the Ryanair flight shouting “Roman Protasevich, put your hands on your head and come with us!” All the passengers, including him, went through a standard set of procedures. What happened after that lies outside the bounds of international law and within the bounds of national legislation – in this case, Belarusian.
Origins of images: Facebook, Twitter, Wikimedia, Wikipedia, Flickr, Google, Imageinjection, Public Domain & Pinterest.
Read our Disclaimer/LegalStatement!
DonatetoSupportUs
We would like to ask you to consider a small donation to help our team keep working. We accept no advertising and rely only on you, our readers, to keep us digging the truth on history, global politics, and international relations.
The negotiations on Brexit are attracting a lot of attention. In particular, the possible erosion of the rights of around three million EU-27 citizens living in Britain is a major cause for concern.The European Parliament resolution adopted on 3 October states that “the withdrawal agreement must incorporate the full set of rights citizens currently enjoy, such that there is no material change in their position”.The main author of this text, Mr Guy Verhofstadt, the EP Brexit Coordinator, argues that such an approach – not to lower the level of citizens’ rights – is “the goal of democracy”. But why was ...
The national scandal unleashed by the Lithuanian Rūta Vanagaitė and the Jewish Efraim Zuroff via their statements about Adolfas Ramanauskas-Vanagas, is gradually losing momentum. The Seimas (parliament) went right ahead and declared the incoming year, 2018, to be The Year of Ramanauskas-Vanagas. That is sad. Three years ago, I wrote about this person’s activities in Druskininkai in 1941. Society back then was silent about it. It was only the desire of some politicians to glorify this personage that led to the aforementioned Lithuanian and Jewish commentators to talk about him. They spoke loudly and an antisemitic bubble burst. Vanagaitė’s statement had some ...
The contemporary Lithuania uses the official interpretation of bloody events that took place in Vilnius on January 13, 1991 as an ideological foundation for Russophobia-based confrontation with its eastern neighbor. It says “the Soviet soldiers committed an intentional murder of 13 unarmed people and one special operations serviceman”. The truth about what really happened, as well as the doubts over the official interpretation, are punishable crimes.The Lithuanian authorities have been trying to get Algirdas Paleckis condemned by court for some years. He is a young politician and a diplomat, the leader of Lithuanian Socialist People’s Front (SPF), a holder of ...
In examining the future, we must look to the past.As we watch the media today, we are spoon fed more and more propaganda and fear of the unknown, that we should be afraid of the unknown and have full faith that our government is keeping us safe from the unknown. But by looking at media today, those of us who are old enough will be reminded of the era of Cold War news articles, hysteria of how the Russians would invade and how we should duck and cover under tables in our kitchens for the ensuing nuclear war.Under this mass ...
Yet again, a conference here in the Lithuanian capital dedicated to combating fascism and antisemitism is announced, without there having been a public call for papers, without a single speaker from among those who actually combat fascism and antisemitism in the country, with nobody from the democratically elected Vilnius Jewish community (not even the long-time editor of Jerusalem of Lithuania who has exposed and combated antisemitism for decades). No Holocaust survivors. None of the nationally relevant questions of the day can be found on the conference program. As ever, outstanding academic personalities from abroad are recruited to lend the gravitas and provide serious papers ...
For the 11th year running, the center of Lithuania’s beautiful capital, Vilnius, was gifted in the high afternoon hours this past Sunday, March 11th, to far-righters and neo-Nazis on the annual holiday cherished by the free world for its historic importance, in 1990, in the series of events that toppled the Soviet Union’s hated misrule. The Defending History community, all resolute admirers of Lithuania who celebrate its success, has monitored this event annually. The international outcry after the 2008 event, which featured “Juden raus” and a throng of swastikas had led to curious “compromises” each year between organizers and the municipality ...
When the excitement subsides or a new political configuration emerges, Protasevich will be dumped into the memory hole like every other imperial agenda pawn.Experience attests that imperial policy makers are anything but morally fastidious when selecting tools for implementing their designs in diverse parts of the world. A notable (and utterly abhorrent) recent example are the Takfiri head-choppers in Syria, who were drafted, daggers and all, to do noble work in that devastated country, spreading the light shining forth from the gleaming city on the hill. Another memorable example is the neo-Nazi scum in the Ukraine, mobilized (and amply funded) ...
In Arabic TV interview, Labour’s ex-London mayor blames Israel for IS attacks in Europe and mass expulsion of Jews from Arab world, again claims Hitler supported ZionismFormer London mayor Ken Livingstone on Wednesday called the creation of Israel “fundamentally wrong,” and “a great catastrophe.” The existence of the Jewish state in the Middle East, he said, could ultimately lead to nuclear war.“The creation of the state of Israel was fundamentally wrong, because there had been a Palestinian community there for 2,000 years,” Livingstone told an Arabic language TV station based in London, in a clip posted and translated by the ...
A picture taken on July 4, 2018 from the Israeli-annexed Syrian Golan Heights shows displaced Syrians from the province of Daraa staging a protest (top L) calling for international protection, in the Syrian the village of al-Rafid, near the border fence with Israel. / AFP PHOTO / JALAA MAREYWith the recent failed bid by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and the Arab League at the UN security council, to try and end Israelis’ occupation of Palestinian land and to create a Palestinian State within the 1967 borders, it seems an appropriate moment to review the situation for Palestinians since 1915.What ...
Origins of images: Facebook, Twitter, Wikimedia, Wikipedia, Flickr, Google, Imageinjection & Pinterest.Read our Disclaimer/Legal Statement!Donate to Support UsWe would like to ask you to consider a small donation to help our team keep working. We accept no advertising and rely only on you, our readers, to keep us digging the truth on history, global politics and international relations.
LONDON — Seventy years after he was shot by the Soviets, the reputation of Jonas Noreika goes on trial in Lithuania next week.Noreika — a hero to many in the Baltic state for resisting the Communists’ subjugation of their country — stands accused of being a Nazi collaborator who was complicit in the Holocaust.Jonas Noreika - "General Storm"The case before the Vilnius Regional Administrative Court charges the state-funded Genocide and Resistance Research Center of Lithuania with intentionally distorting the role of Noreika in the murder of Jews.It has been brought by Grant Gochin, a Lithuanian citizen living in the US, ...
The outbursts of anti-Russian rhetoric of Lithuanian President Dalia Grybauskaitė is certainly very bizarre in view of her curriculum vitae. Dalia Grybauskaitė is a very educated woman. Because of the free education system of the former USSR, she was able to complete her university education at the elite Saint Petersburg State University. She became a member of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in 1983, some five years before she earned a doctoral degree at the prestigious Academy of Social Sciences in Moscow. It is generally known that not every applicant is routinely accepted to become a Party member.This ...
The stars came out in Hollywood on November 2nd, or at least some of them did. The gala event celebrated the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and raised funds to support its mission in Israel itself and on the occupied West Bank. The organization being fêted was the Friends of the Israel Defense Forces (FIDF), which has fourteen regional offices in the United States and operates under the slogan “Their job is to look after Israel. Our job is to look after them.” In attendance were Arnold Schwarzenegger and actor Gerald Butler. Entertainment was provided by the singer Seal.Hollywood Jewish royalty ...
I am a Lithuanian, but I leave abroad and I am not going back. At least now, at least until the Government does not pay attention to its people. According to some authoritative research institutes, during 2017 Lithuania population is again projected to decrease (by 45 677 people!) and reach 2 758 290 in the beginning of 2018. (http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/lithuania-population/). As of 1 January 2017, the population of Lithuania was estimated to be 2 803 967 people. This is a decrease of 1.63 % (46 433 people) compared to population of 2 850 400 the year before. In other words, our ...
Belarus' fighter jet-assisted diversion of a Ryanair flight to Minsk in response to an ostensible bomb threat onboard and subsequent arrest of an extremist member of the country's Color Revolution movement upon landing might open Pandora's Box by setting the precedent whereby Western countries might eventually follow in its footsteps for purely political reasons against unilaterally sanctioned individuals from Russia or elsewhere.Belarus ordered a fighter jet to escort a Ryanair flight to Minsk that was transiting through its airspace en route to Vilnius on Sunday in response to an ostensible bomb threat onboard. Upon landing, an extremist member of the ...
The title page of Rūta Vanagaitė’s best-known book contains two pictures of young men. “This one is a Jew,” she said, pointing at the picture on the left. “He was a bicycle-racing champion. Good enough to represent Lithuania in international competitions, but not good enough to live.” He was executed during the Holocaust. The man in the picture on the right was a Lithuanian executioner. “They are both us,” Vanagaitė explained. “But Lithuanians don’t like to think of them as ‘us,’ because one is a Jew and the other is a killer.” Her book is called “Us.” (The title has ...
Yom HaShoah/Holocaust Remembrance Day: A state-sponsored institution in Vilnius rewrites history to the delight of Europe’s new ultranationalistsThis past winter here in Vilnius, the charming capital of Lithuania, was much like any other. During long solid weeks of subzero temperatures, as the flow of tourists and roots-seekers slowed to a trickle, I adjusted the route of my daily walk to pass by up to a dozen top tourist sights. Day after day, there was one constant: The most popular, winter-defying “must-visit” for foreigners is “The Museum of Genocide Victims.” Perhaps there is something grotesquely sexy about “genocide.” Maybe the promise ...
Unlike America under Donald Trump, who is proudly psychopathic and went so far as to blurt out that his followers would accept his leadership even if he were to shoot someone on Fifth Avenue, the European Union is so rabidly hypocritical (Trump would probably call it "politically correct") that its leaders routinely moralize about 'human rights and democracy' even while their governments indiscriminately rob and slaughter people in foreign lands (as will be documented here). EU leaders assist U.S.-led atrocities while using prettier language to describe their alleged motivation for these policies. Though the U.S. Government also occasionally employs such ...
Belarus is a land known also as Belorussia (White Russia, Weißrussland) in East Europe which was for centuries occupied by a Polish-Lithuanian common state until it became included in Tsarist Russia in the late 18th century.[1] Belarus is facing many identity problems but the most important is the ethnolinguistic challenge to a separate Belarussian[2] national feature.National identityA common national identity is a focal element for the creation of a national state as without a common identity that is based on a fundamental element of group’s identity a psychological sense of common solidarity cannot be developed. However, such solidarity is a ...
New scandalous information about the 2014 Maidan coup d'état in Ukraine has emerged that implicates Lithuania’s important role in instigating the violent events. David Zhvania, a former Member of the Ukrainian Parliament, revealed on his YouTube channel that the seizure of power in Ukraine was financed in “several ways.”“One of the external sources was the Lithuanian embassy, through which money and weapons were transferred, and the internal channel was Diamantbank. I have documented evidence to support my words,” said the former ally of Petro Poroshenko, the previous president of Ukraine.Zhvania called on Prosecutor General Irina Venediktova to initiate criminal proceedings ...